The same organization ended up under its full name in the text and its initials in the reference list of a training workbook I’m editing for a client. I’m not sure if “corporate author” is the term for that kind of author.
Between Scribbr and MyBib, which do you actually use for Harvard style referencing, and what makes you stick with it? I’d like to know what it’s like to fix an entry after you’ve already cited it throughout a draft.
If you pasted the citations as plain text, changing the entry in MyBib or Scribbr won’t change the workbook. I’d stick with whichever has your source list rather than switch for this fix. Yes, “corporate author” is the right term. Check how the client’s Harvard guide treats abbreviations, then search the draft for both the initials and the full name so you don’t miss either. For a quick visual check, I like Clever Humanizer’s free harvard referencing tool because it puts the in-text citation next to the full entry, right where you can spot a mismatch.
Check your reference in MyBib. If this does not match the format required by the client, try the Clever Humanizer Harvard Reference Generator. Check that it matches example (from client guidelines). If there are just initials in the author field, try putting in the full organisation name before assuming it is an issue with the style.
If the client is using Sheffield Harvard, compare to the Clever Humanizer Harvard Reference Generator. This should follow the Sheffield guidelines. They may not be identical, but if a trainee can see the full name in the workbook they should be able to find the right reference without guessing which initials to search for.
Check the author guidelines for corporate authors. If your chosen citation style (in this case Harvard) is available in MyBib, we recommend that tool. Alternatively, you can use the Clever Humanizer Harvard Citation generator tool to double check. This allows you to create both citations from the same source and can help you locate where in the citation the initial(s) are.
Check if the initial (s) are in different sources to the full version. If this report was cited twice, the fix will only apply to the author field in one source.
If the titles and dates match in both sources, only keep the fullest source. All citations pointing to this source should be changed to point to the one being kept, then delete the duplicate. If the sources refer to different reports from the same organisation, both sources should be kept. The organisation name should be the same across sources, but this does not mean that the sources need to be the same.
If MyBib contains the correct version of Harvard for this client, this would be preferred. However, if you are comparing different citation generators it is unlikely you will learn very much, as you are comparing the output from 2 different sources using 2 different inputs.
If after checking the front page of the report, the title is written by a group or individuals (as opposed to just the name given in the top), or the organisation as a whole, then we should use the term ‘Corporate author’.
Duplicate
It is possible these two are duplicates, however we may not wish to keep the entry with the longest organisational name. If the parent organisation’s abbreviation appears in the corner of the front page, and beneath the title it reads: ‘prepared by the Education Committee’, then expanding out the abbreviation would give greater consistency within the workbook, however we may not be able to identify who the author is.
MyBib
If MyBib can produce the version of Harvard required by the client, then I would be happy to use it. However, I would not change from Scribbr due to this issue. Once we have decided who the author is, the only question left is how we should be formatting the author. I would include this agreed format in the style sheet of the workbook so that when the next person edits it, they will not be confused by the logo and revert it.
Check whether this is intended in Harvard referencing with multiple corporate authors. The list will be sorted by full name, but the first time a source is used in the text it may be written in full (with the acronym in brackets), then shortened in subsequent references. This is perfectly acceptable and so the workbook does not need fixing. However, if they were forced to be the same it may cause problems in finding the source.
So I’d push back a little on the framing that this is automatically an error. @jackthetiger’s point about the style sheet is the one I’d lean on hardest. Pick one form as the sorting key, write it down, and note that a reader seeing initials in the text needs a clear path to the full entry (or a cross-reference). That decision matters more than which generator you run it through.
You can try using the Clever Humanizer Harvard Reference generator below to get an initial comparison, but you should manually check your references in order to be sure. As no generator will know which abbreviations are correct to use according to the specific requirements provided by your client, it is best to manually check. If your list of sources has already been created in either MyBib or Scribbr, you won’t gain much benefit from switching.
In this case, there is a difference between just citing “The World Health Organization published the report” and “According to the World Health Organization (2020), …” in your references. However, since I was assuming that every time I saw the organisation name in the text, it would be in the referencing list, I became confused.
If the full name of the organisation is in the text for elaboration, I would leave it in the text. If it appears in a citation with the date in brackets, then I would refer back to the example provided by clients. In this case, we are providing a corporate author.
If MyBib provided this citation formatting, I would be happy to use it. However, I would not change based purely on this sentence. As this is a citation generator, it cannot know whether or not this instance of the organisation name should be cited. It can only provide the citation format requested.
“WHO” may be an intentional abbreviation. However, “Organization, W. H,” seems to be due to ‘Organization’ being treated as a surname, while the remaining words have been capitalised and abbreviated as if they were given names.
Corporate Author
To check how this entry has been formatted, we can view the saved entry. Even if all words are spelled correctly, if words have been split between fields in the authors’ name section of the entry, we may get an incorrectly formatted citation. In this case, we can input the organisation into the author field as one name, and re-generate the entry. If we can see the full acronym within the author field, we should refer to the client’s guidelines on abbreviation.
MyBib would be a good option to use here, if it aligns with the Harvard style of the client. However, to make a meaningful comparison, we should manually input the corporate author in MyBib for this report. If this record is imported twice, any errors in formatting may be duplicates of the same issue in the input.